| « Slavery and the Bible | Quick poll » |
What if
Here's a thought experiment. What would happen if some authoritative Christian body, such as the Episcopal Church, came out with a new version of the Bible with the worst of the bad stuff removed? There would be some backlash, of course. But what if the redactions were limited to a short list of indefensible verses? Let's say the new version left out Leviticus 25:44-46. Would Christians protest this new version? Would they fight to have the slavery-condoning verses included? If you are a Christian, would you refuse to use a Bible that excluded those verses?
I have follow-up questions, but I would like to see what people think about the initial question before I bring them out.
7 comments
The folks who think the Bible is the holy and perfect word of God would obviously object loudly.
But I think people who see the Bible as a historical document, as a set of human-written spiritual insights, or as a combination of the two, would not want to see any of it taken out either. For these people the "bad stuff" is easily understood in a cultural context, and is an important part of history.
I recently finished reading a translation of Psalms by Robert Alter that looks at the book in a purely historical and cultural light. Even he shows a great unwillingness to alter (sorry, I couldn't resist) the received text, even in cases where he said there were clear scribal errors. He occasionally "fixes" such minor mistakes as a single miscopied letter, but otherwise he wants his translation to reflect the message and content of the Hebrew text as it has been used by Jews and Christians for thousands of years, not necessarily as the original writers (or God, if that's your view) may have intended.
I think I prefer it this way too.
Didn't something like this go down when the Catholic Church decided using a dead language was stupid? Didn't the "faithful" have a hissy fit because they wanted their sessions to be unintelligible to any living human? And then each time the Pope Dude does the ... what do you call it when they have a big todo over what the deal is ... ? When they decide that yeah okay so some stuff is different now but hey we gotta keep most everything the same so here's some change that people can have a hissy fit about even though nothing's really gonna change and young boys just gotta man up and shut up? Every 10 or 12 years it happens. Damn but I can't recall the term for it. Oh well. At any rate I'd guess the same thing would happen with a 'modernized' version: total freak out by those more into the habits of procedure than that which is actually available to anyone willing to think through a belief system.
I don't know how anyone can answer how all Christians would react. How would all African Americans or all sci-fi geeks react?
I probably wouldn't care much. Unless I was trying to look up those verses. Then I'd just be frustrated.
The presence of outdated ideas in religious texts is only a problem when people insist on only interpreting those texts literally.
The way to solve that is to get people to develop a more well-rounded view of scripture, not to just get rid of the offending passages.
Leave a comment
Search Cloud
- top 10 break up songs
- cool company name
- you look good wearing my future
- breaking up songs
- fake company
- best worship songs
- fake company list
- break up songs
- songs about breaking up but still being in love
- b2evolution skins
- best fuck you songs
- song about breaking up
- angry break up songs
- best goodbye songs
- top worship songs
- good breakup songs
- "you look good wearing my future"
- cool company names list
- top 10 breakup songs
- top break up songs
- auir
- motivator generator
- songs for breaking up
- cool company names
- list of company names
- good break up songs
- company names list
- you look good wearing my future movie
- i hate you songs
- songs about splitting up
- fake company names
- cool names for companies
- fake companies
- best break up songs
- songs about breaking up
- my life for auir
- list of best presidents
- top ten break up songs
- emma games
- good worship songs






Recent comments